I can’t even count the endless hours and dollars in ingredients I’ve spent trying to bake wholesome high-protein muffins, bars and pancakes, only to have it all go to waste. URGH!!!!! Here’s the reality: baking with vegan protein powder most often does not work well at all. It’s a texture thing. A vegan protein just does not have the same fluffly, light and raising texture that a good whey protein does.

It is dense, gritty-like, and most often results in a baked good that seems uncooked, even when doubling the baking time. This makes me sad, and very frustrated (as I stare at the mess in my muffin tins as I write this). As a holistic nutrition expert, I know the value of variety in our food sources. So rotating a good quality vegan protein powder with a whey isolate is ideal. Also, many people are diary-sensitive (whether lactose, casein or both) and cannot have whey protein powder.

The very few times (maybe once?!) I’ve ever had success with a vegan protein powder (and I’ve tried several types and brands) that success was lost when I had to play with the other ingredients to accomodate for an individuals unique needs; ie: substituting flax when there’s an egg allergy.

In the spirit of sharing, and to try to save you a fraction of the frustration I’ve encountered, here’s my advice:

* use your vegan protein powder in your smoothies or no-bake recipes (like my apple chia pudding recipe yum!)
* for your baked goods, use a clean whey isolate such as my favorite – Dynamis white chocolate brownie flavor, this is a winner even among the whey protein for baking
* if you do find a baking recipes that works really well with a vegan protein powder, please share!

UPDATED INFO, April 2025:

The reason whey protein works so much better for baking than most plant-based proteins is because of its structure and behavior when heated.

---

Here’s Why Whey Protein Bakes Better:

1. It Acts Like Egg Whites

• Whey protein is high in albumin-like proteins, similar to what’s found in egg whites.

• When heated, it coagulates (solidifies) and helps bind, rise, and create a fluffy structure — kind of like what eggs do in a cake.

2. It’s Soluble and Smooth

• Whey mixes well with liquid and doesn’t stay gritty or dense.

• This helps create a better texture in baked goods, especially things like muffins, pancakes, or protein brownies.

3. Neutral Flavor and Color

• It usually doesn’t overpower other ingredients the way earthy or grainy plant proteins can.

---

Why Plant-Based Proteins Don’t Bake the Same

Most plant-based protein powders are made from pea, rice, hemp, soy, or a blend — and they behave very differently:

• Pea Protein – tends to make things dense and dry

• Hemp Protein – gritty, earthy, doesn’t rise well

• Brown Rice Protein – chalky, very absorbent

• Soy Protein – closer to whey, but still lacks the lightness and flexibility of whey

They don’t coagulate or trap air well when baked, which leads to flat, dense, or crumbly results.

---

Want to Use Plant Protein for Baking?

You can make it work — it just needs more support. Here’s how:

Add Moisture + Binders:

• Mix with nut butter, banana, applesauce, or pumpkin to keep it moist.

• Use extra eggs or flax eggs to help bind and rise.

Combine with Whey (if not strictly plant-based)

• A 50/50 blend of whey and plant protein can offer better structure.

Use baking powder + vinegar or lemon juice

• This combo helps mimic a little of the rise you get from whey.

---

Summary

Whey protein works so well because it acts like eggs: it binds, rises, and creates fluffy, moist baked goods. Plant proteins don’t have the same structure or solubility.

Now we know

Want access to loads of protein enhanced delicious baking recipes, easy meal prep dishes, and more?  Check out our RxHABITS membership – we dish out loads of new recipes all.the.time!