I can’t even count the endless hours and dollars in ingredients I’ve spent trying to bake wholesome high-protein muffins, bars and pancakes, only to have it all go to waste. URGH!!!!! Here’s the reality: baking with vegan protein powder most often does not work well at all. It’s a texture thing. A vegan protein just does not have the same fluffly, light and raising texture that a good whey protein does.

It is dense, gritty-like, and most often results in a baked good that seems uncooked, even when doubling the baking time. This makes me sad, and very frustrated (as I stare at the mess in my muffin tins as I write this). As a holistic nutrition expert, I know the value of variety in our food sources. So rotating a good quality vegan protein powder with a whey isolate is ideal. Also, many people are diary-sensitive (whether lactose, casein or both) and cannot have whey protein powder.

The very few times (maybe once?!) I’ve ever had success with a vegan protein powder (and I’ve tried several types and brands) that success was lost when I had to play with the other ingredients to accomodate for an individuals unique needs; ie: substituting flax when there’s an egg allergy.

In the spirit of sharing, and to try to save you a fraction of the frustration I’ve encountered, here’s my advice:

* use your vegan protein powder in your smoothies or no-bake recipes (like my apple chia pudding recipe yum!)
* for your baked goods, use a clean whey isolate such as my favorite – Dynamis white chocolate brownie flavor, this is a winner even among the whey protein for baking
* if you do find a baking recipes that works really well with a vegan protein powder, please share! 🙂

UPDATED INFO, April 2025:

The reason whey protein works so much better for baking than most plant-based proteins is because of its structure and behavior when heated.

---

🧪 Here’s Why Whey Protein Bakes Better:

1. It Acts Like Egg Whites

• Whey protein is high in albumin-like proteins, similar to what’s found in egg whites.

• When heated, it coagulates (solidifies) and helps bind, rise, and create a fluffy structure — kind of like what eggs do in a cake.

2. It’s Soluble and Smooth

• Whey mixes well with liquid and doesn’t stay gritty or dense.

• This helps create a better texture in baked goods, especially things like muffins, pancakes, or protein brownies.

3. Neutral Flavor and Color

• It usually doesn’t overpower other ingredients the way earthy or grainy plant proteins can.

---

🌱 Why Plant-Based Proteins Don’t Bake the Same

Most plant-based protein powders are made from pea, rice, hemp, soy, or a blend — and they behave very differently:

• Pea Protein – tends to make things dense and dry

• Hemp Protein – gritty, earthy, doesn’t rise well

• Brown Rice Protein – chalky, very absorbent

• Soy Protein – closer to whey, but still lacks the lightness and flexibility of whey

They don’t coagulate or trap air well when baked, which leads to flat, dense, or crumbly results.

---

🔧 Want to Use Plant Protein for Baking?

You can make it work — it just needs more support. Here’s how:

✅ Add Moisture + Binders:

• Mix with nut butter, banana, applesauce, or pumpkin to keep it moist.

• Use extra eggs or flax eggs to help bind and rise.

✅ Combine with Whey (if not strictly plant-based)

• A 50/50 blend of whey and plant protein can offer better structure.

✅ Use baking powder + vinegar or lemon juice

• This combo helps mimic a little of the rise you get from whey.

---

📌 Summary

Whey protein works so well because it acts like eggs: it binds, rises, and creates fluffy, moist baked goods. Plant proteins don’t have the same structure or solubility.

Now we know 🤓

Want access to loads of protein enhanced delicious baking recipes, easy meal prep dishes, and more?  Check out our RxHABITS membership – we dish out loads of new recipes all.the.time!